The acoustic differences between the two platters are subtle but noticeable. It is worth mentioning that your cartridge has a much larger impact on playback quality/character than the platter material you choose. So if you upgrade one thing on your table, we generally recommend starting with the cartridge.
No matter which material you choose, all of our platters go through the same comprehensive quality control process prior to shipping. This includes wow & flutter and frequency deviation measurements as well as a qualitative listening test. We also use a digital microscope to make sure there is no platter wobble. And, at the end of the day, if you start with the basic MDF you can easily upgrade to the acrylic platter down the road.
Please leave comments and questions below. If you are interested in more content like this, tell us! If you aren't, tell us what you would like to see! We are excited to get this whole blog thing rolling.